Jaimie Alexander

Liz Chambers

Brian McNamara

Sheriff O'Connor

Ethan Phillips

Preacher

Chloë Grace Moretz

Sabrina

Ned Vaughn

Deputy Mark Simmons

Jim Cody Williams

Earl

Tamara Clatterbuck

Waitress

Nick Chinlund

Jonas Hathaway

Hudson Leick

Sarah Austin

Dan Warner

Officer Chandler

Randy Ross

Farmer

Steve Larkin

Mayor

Fred Meyers

Lanky Teenager

Time Winters

Victim

William Stanford Davis

Truck Driver

Rico E. Anderson

Crucified Man

Ryan Honey

Sabrina's Father

Walter Phelan

Scarecrow

Rachel Grodnik

Farm Girl