Selma Blair

Patti Petalson

Patrick Wilson

Brian Callahan

Edward Burns

Michael Murphy

Debra Messing

Kate Scott

Dennis Farina

Gilmore

Dara Coleman

Silent Movie Actor

Heather Goldenhersh

Sassy Party-Goer

Sarah Hudnut

Scare-a Sara

Elizabeth Reaser

Bernadette

Rosemarie DeWitt

Murph's Hampton's Fling

Peter Van Wagner

Mr. Sabatini

PT Walkley

Singer / Songwriter

Bob Wiltfong

Bookstore Representative

Donal Logue

Chazz Coleman

Jay Patterson

Michael's Agent

Peter Jacobson

Monroe - Real estate agent

Joe Pistone

Top Cat

Bill Hader

Bill - Bookstore Fan