Luca and his knucklehead buddy Tommy head to a speed dating event on a Tuesday evening in their suburban Long Island hometown. They each meet a variety of daters throughout the evening until Luca eventually meets Natalie. There is an instant connection between them with dialogue flowing from President Nixon, The Beatles, their viewpoints on love, and Italian cured meats. The bell rings, their date ends, and the probabilities of them falling in love is purely statistical...or is it?.